I Can Be Replaced

Recently it was reported that:

A US opera company has struck a deal with a musicians' union banning the use of a computerised "virtual orchestra". Under the deal the Opera Company of Brooklyn will use live musicians rather than technology which replicates them. The move was hailed by the American Federation of Musicians as "a victory for live music, talented artists and the audience". (BBC News)

The question for all of us is: What is the value of live music? In an increasingly digital age, recordings and computerized replications of actual instruments are fast becoming the norm. They are technically more perfect, cheaper, and more punctual than most musicians.

As I see it, a computer no matter how technically perfect is not expressing anything. It merely plays notes of different volumes and pitches. It has no inner turmoil to convey, no inner peace to share. Music is not about perfect performances; it is about expression. Until a computer can cry, laugh, shout with all the feelings that back those up, I’m not listening.

Just For Fun…

Answer these riddles three and a new CD shall be sent to thee. (Actually there is just one riddle, but three rhymes better)

What color hat does William wear at the Bistro Solieil?